Earlier this summer, I blogged about the addition of crimes of aggression to the International Criminal Court’s jurisdiction. The ICC adopted the resolution after years of controversy, and since the resolution’s adoption, there has been increased debate on the new crime’s potential effectiveness.
The ICC’s ability to prosecute a crime of aggression revolves around a very loose definition, and determining when such a crime has been committed will be primarily (but not exclusively) decided by the United Nations Security Council. This creates a host of issues, including whether any state or person will actually face the charge; whether actions such as humanitarian missions could be considered acts of aggression; and whether the crime will become politically charged by the political actors on the Security Council.
I find the definition to be too malleable, and obstacles standing in the way of effective enforcement are immense. I could write at length explaining this, but in the interest of delivering a concise blog, I thought it might be helpful to at least highlight other resources/opinions on the matter.
First, the Council on Foreign Relations has published a brief look at the crime, which is summarized:
The idea of holding national leaders to account for waging wars of aggression has moral appeal and historical pedigree. But whether the International Criminal Court can try such cases is a thornier issue.
The full text can be found here.
Another contrarian view can be found at the Foreign Policy Blog, in a posting written by David Bosco. He chronicles a potentially controversial, yet pragmatic position.
Finally, if you are interested in a longer, more detailed study of the problem, you should consider Oscar Solera’s writings. Mr. Solera has written extensively about adopting a standard for a crime of aggression, and earlier this year, before the ICC Conference, published a paper, The Definition of the Crime of Aggression: Lessons Not Learned. For those invested in the topic and unfamiliar with Mr. Solera’s writings, I highly recommend it.